Why your core values and intrinsic motivation—not PRs, podiums, or Strava kudos—are what sustain you through setbacks, injury, and life transitions.
You lace up your shoes for another training session, but something feels off. Maybe you're battling the voice in your head telling you you're not good enough, that one missed interval proves you're a failure. Or maybe you're coming back from injury, wondering if you can trust your body again. Perhaps you're in the middle of a big life transition—perimenopause, a career change, stepping back from competition—and questioning who you are without the athletic identity you've built your life around.
Or maybe you're scrolling through Strava after a workout, waiting for the kudos to roll in, needing that external validation to feel like the session counted. You show up, you go through the motions, but the fire that used to drive you has dimmed to barely a flicker.
If any of this sounds familiar, you're not simply struggling with motivation or discipline. You're experiencing what happens when your "why" gets buried under self-criticism, setbacks, life transitions, and the constant pressure to prove yourself worthy of taking up space in your sport.
Why Your "Why" Matters More Than Your PR
Here's what decades of sport psychology research point to: athletes who are driven by intrinsic motivation and a clear sense of personal values tend to experience greater long-term adherence to their sport, more resilience during setbacks, and higher overall satisfaction [1][3]. Self-Determination Theory (SDT)—one of the most studied frameworks in this field—describes a spectrum from autonomous motivation (doing your sport because you enjoy it and because it genuinely matters to you) to controlled motivation (doing it for rewards, or to avoid guilt and shame) [1].
Most of us get so fixated on results—PRs, podiums, Strava segments—that we lose touch with the deeper reasons we started in the first place. And when performance inevitably fluctuates (because it always does), our entire sense of self can feel threatened.
The research offers an encouraging nuance here. Recognizing your sport as personally valuable is especially powerful for getting started and staying consistent, while genuine enjoyment is what best sustains a sport over the long haul [1]. By contrast, when your training is driven mainly by external pressure or guilt, motivation tends to be more fragile—it works until it doesn't [1][2]. A large prospective study of youth athletes found a striking gradient: the more controlled (and less autonomous) an athlete's motivation, the more likely they were to drop out the following season [2]. Your "why" is the foundation that holds steady when race results don't go as planned.
The Hidden Cost of an Outcome-Based Athletic Identity
When your self-worth rises and falls entirely with your results, sport becomes a riskier place for your mental health. Research shows that athletes whose identity is exclusively tied to their athletic role are more vulnerable to anxiety, to depressive symptoms after disappointing performances, and to a harder time coping with injury and with retirement or other life transitions [4][5][6]. One study of elite athletes found that the shame that follows a performance failure may be a key driver linking "I'm only valuable when I perform well" thinking to both competitive anxiety and burnout [9].
It's worth being clear: a strong athletic identity isn't inherently a bad thing. It can fuel commitment, rehabilitation after injury, and resilience [4]. The risk comes when that identity becomes exclusive—when it crowds out every other part of who you are, a pattern sport psychologists call identity foreclosure [7]. A multidimensional sense of self—interests, relationships, and roles beyond sport—is one of the strongest protective factors against the distress that can accompany injury or the end of a competitive career [4][6].
So when your self-worth crashes with one disappointing workout, when you can't shake the fear while rebuilding after injury, when life changes force you to redefine who you are, or when you need constant external validation just to feel like you belong—those are signals that your "why" needs attention.
Think about it: if someone asked you right now, "Why do you do your sport?" could you answer beyond "to get faster," "to prove I'm good enough," or "because it's all I've ever known"? If those goalposts or identities shifted tomorrow, would you still show up?
What Finding Your "Why" as an Athlete Actually Looks Like
Finding your "why" isn't about manufacturing some inspirational quote to post on Instagram. It's about identifying what genuinely matters to you beyond any single result, setback, or life chapter—the values and intrinsic motivations that make your sport meaningful regardless of where you are in your journey.
Maybe it's the courage you practice when you face your fears on the start line or in your first workout back from injury. Maybe it's the self-compassion you're learning as your body changes through perimenopause or chronic health challenges. Maybe it's the authenticity you bring when you show up as your full self in a sport that hasn't always made space for people like you. Or maybe it's simply the challenge, growth, connection, or freedom you experience—the things that drew you to sport in the first place, before performance pressure took over.
These aren't frivolous nice-to-haves. Values-based, autonomous motivation predicts better long-term adherence than motivation driven by guilt or obligation [1], and it's also been linked to greater resilience in athletes [3]. When you're clear on your core values, decisions get easier, setbacks sting less, and your athletic identity can handle whatever comes your way.
As we discuss in our guide to building sustainable habits, lasting change happens when your daily actions align with what truly matters to you. The same principle applies to your entire relationship with sport.
Goals vs. Values: What's the Difference for Athletes?
Here's a crucial distinction that many athletes don't necessarily consider: goals are destinations you reach or don't reach. Values are directions you move in—always accessible, regardless of outcomes [8]. This difference sits at the heart of acceptance and commitment approaches to performance, where values are defined as freely chosen, ongoing directions rather than achievable endpoints [8].
I often tell athletes that values are kind of like your favorite kind of pizza. They're inherent—not something we can just pick because it sounds good. Just like with pizza, we're naturally drawn to certain kinds. We can try to change our minds, but at the end of the day, we can't really control our preferences. Values are similar; they're simply how we're wired. To identify your values, reflect on what you want to be known for as an athlete. What word would you want people to use to describe you?
"Qualify for nationals" is a goal. You achieve it or you don't. "Train with courage" is a value. You can succeed at living it today, tomorrow, and next week—whether you PR, have a terrible race, or get injured.
This doesn't mean goals don't matter. They absolutely do. But when your goals are grounded in clear values, they become more meaningful and your motivation becomes more sustainable [1][8]. We explored this in why New Year's resolutions fail, because intentions beat empty goal-setting every time.
How to Reconnect With Your Original Motivation for Sport
Most athletes can remember a time when their sport felt different—lighter, more joyful, less loaded with pressure and expectation. Before it became about times and rankings and proving yourself. That version of you had a "why" that wasn't dependent on external validation. Somewhere along the way, achievement became the primary driver, and the deeper motivations got buried.
The good news? They're not gone. They're just buried under years of "shoulds" and external expectations. And reconnecting with them doesn't require abandoning your competitive goals or lowering your standards. In fact, pursuing what you value—rather than avoiding failure—has been linked to greater resilience and well-being [8], which only makes you steadier in chasing the results you want. As we discuss in our post on consistency over intensity, sustainable performance requires a foundation that can weather the long game. That foundation is your "why."
How to Find Your Why: Why It Takes More Than a Quick Fix
If you're reading this and thinking, "Okay, but how do I actually figure out my why?"—you're not alone. This isn't work you can knock out in a 10-minute journaling session. It requires intentional reflection, honest self-assessment, and often some uncomfortable questions about who you are as an athlete beyond your results. Encouragingly, structured values- and acceptance-based programs have been shown to shift athletes toward more intrinsic motivation and to support performance and well-being [10].
This is exactly the work we're doing together in the Skadi Community membership. The Find Your Why challenge is dedicated entirely to helping you reconnect with your "why": identifying your core athletic values, crafting a personal "why" statement, and building practical tools to stay grounded when motivation wanes or results disappoint.
You'll have access to guided exercises, expert coaching from Dr. Erin Ayala, and a community of athletes doing the same work alongside you. You won't just think about your "why." You'll create a toolkit you can actually use before races, during hard training blocks, or when you're questioning if this is all worth it.
If you're tired of basing your self-worth on race results, or if training has started to feel like checking boxes instead of something you genuinely want to do, this is your invitation. Join the Skadi Community and start building an athletic identity that's resilient, sustainable, and authentically yours. Learn more and join us here.
References
Teixeira PJ, Carraça EV, Markland D, Silva MN, Ryan RM. Exercise, physical activity, and self-determination theory: a systematic review. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity. 2012.
Nielsen G, Wikman JM, Appleton PR, Bentsen P, Elsborg P. Predicting adolescents' continuation in club sports: a prospective cohort study. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports. 2024.
Trigueros R, Aguilar-Parra JM, Cangas-Díaz AJ, et al. The influence of the trainer on the motivation and resilience of sportspeople: a study from the perspective of self-determination theory. PLoS One. 2019.
Chang CJ, Putukian M, Aerni G, et al. Mental health issues and psychological factors in athletes: American Medical Society for Sports Medicine position statement. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. 2020.
Park AL, Furie K, Wong SE. Stronger athlete identity is a risk factor for more severe depressive symptoms after musculoskeletal injury in pediatric athletes: a systematic review. Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine.2023.
Schmid J, Conzelmann A, Engel R, Kuettel A, Schmid MJ. Retirement from elite sport and self-esteem: a longitudinal study over 12 years. Frontiers in Psychology. 2023.
Brewer BW, Petitpas AJ. Athletic identity foreclosure. Current Opinion in Psychology. 2017.
Ceary CD, Donahue JJ, Shaffer K. The strength of pursuing your values: valued living as a path to resilience among college students. Stress and Health. 2019.
Funke A, Gustafsson H. Shame following performance failure as a potential mediator between sport-contingent self-esteem and both competitive anxiety and burnout among elite athletes. Acta Psychologica. 2026.
Lundgren T, Reinebo G, Jansson-Fröjmark M, et al. Acceptance and commitment training for ice hockey players: a randomized controlled trial. Frontiers in Psychology. 2021.

